Maintenance Detective: The Tripped Motor Overload
The call: a conveyor is down. The overload on the motor starter has tripped.
The setup:
• 240V, 3-phase supply
• Dual-voltage motor, wired for low voltage
• Across-the-line starter with an overload relay
Before I do anything, I verify I have followed all of my organization's safety protocols.
And since I'm already in the panel, I put my meter on the load side (bottom) of the tripped overload and check the motor circuit phase-to-phase:
Blue – Red: OL
Red – Black: 1.2 Ω
Black – Blue: OL
Two questions:
1. Why did the overload trip?
2. What's the most probable cause, and where do you look first?

Answer:
Why did the overload trip?
The motor was single-phasing. With the blue phase lost, it tried to carry the conveyor on two lines. Current in the remaining phases climbs well above normal, the windings heat up, and the overload does exactly what it's there for. (If the phase dropped while the motor was stopped, it would just hum at locked-rotor current until it tripped.)
Most probable cause:
The blue conductor is open somewhere between the overload and the motor. It's a wiring problem, not a motor problem.
Here's why:
A dual-voltage motor has two coil groups per phase. Wired for high voltage, they're in series. Wired for low voltage, they're in PARALLEL. That means every line feeds the motor through two separate paths.
Now break a coil inside the motor. Its parallel partner still carries current, so you won't see OL. You'll see imbalance. Do the math on a parallel delta and one broken coil gives about a 33% spread between readings. A parallel wye gives about 50%. Both fail the field rule of thumb that phase-to-phase readings should match within 10%.
So the meter gives you two different signatures:
• Readings out of balance: suspect the motor windings have an issue.
• Two OLs: suspect the wire.
A note on meters: any meter will find an OL. Balance checks are different. On a motor that reads around an ohm or less, a standard meter's resolution and lead resistance can be bigger than the difference you're looking for. Use a milliohm meter. If you're checking balance on a 700 milliohm motor with a meter that reads to a tenth of an ohm, you're guessing.
To get OL on BOTH pairs that include blue, the break has to be in the one place where blue has only a single path: the wire from the overload to the motor, before it splits into the two motor leads.
The bigger principle:
Two OLs on a motor with parallel paths points to the wiring, not the windings. That covers more motors than you'd think:
• Any dual-voltage motor on its low-voltage connection, wye or delta
• Any delta-wound motor at any voltage. The windings form a triangle, so every pair of leads has two paths: through one winding, or the long way around through the other two.
The exception: a wye-wound motor on its high-voltage connection (a very common 480V setup). There each phase is one series path, so an open phase winding gives the same two-OL pattern as a broken wire. It COULD be the motor.
Even then, chase the wire first. Loose and broken connections are far more common than a cleanly open winding. Then prove it at the motor (below) before you condemn anything.
Where to look (still locked out):
• Load-side lugs on the overload and contactor: loose screws, backed-out wires
• Terminal strips in the cabinet: loose or pulled conductors
• Any local disconnect at the conveyor: a failed pole or a blown fuse
• Every junction box between the panel and the motor: wire nuts fall off, splices corrode apart, conveyor vibration works things loose
• The motor's connection box: same story
Fast way to find it:
Open the motor connection box, lift the field wires, and meter the motor leads directly. Balanced readings mean the motor is fine. Then jumper the blue and red field wires together at the motor and meter them back at the panel. Still OL? The break is in blue. Work the junction boxes from there.
Before returning to service:
Repair and torque every connection you touched. The motor ran hot while single-phasing, so a megger test is cheap insurance. Once it's running, check amps on all three phases.
And if there is one loose wire in that cabinet, there are probably more. You might want to schedule someone to tighten all those lugs on the next scheduled downtime.
Safety: Every check here is done de-energized, locked out, and verified.
A tripped overload makes nothing safe.
The line side is still live, and a contactor is not a disconnect.
The lesson:
When two out of three readings are OL, think wiring before windings. Wire first, then prove the motor at the motor.
Need help with a difficult maintenance problem?
180 IMT provides industrial maintenance troubleshooting and support for manufacturers.
Want to prevent recurring equipment problems?
180 OPEX helps manufacturers build the standards and verification systems that keep problems from coming back.






Comments